What is Solipsism?

Are minds real? Do humans have free will? Is evolution true?

Solipsism is the idea that only one’s own mind is certain to exist.

Very few people are sincere solipsists. Instead, solipsism is generally used as an argumentation tool. For example, one might ask how another knows that something is true, to which a scoffing reply might be “How does anyone know that anything is true? The only thing we can know for sure is that we exist.”

This point of view is related to René Descartes’ famous line: I think, therefore I am. Descartes wrote about his philosophy as if he were the first to ever do so…that is, he didn’t take into account any previous philosophical positions about truth when writing, and wanted to avoid making any assumptions when thinking about reality. This is the basis for modern philosophy (which I love, and studied in college) and a reasonable position to take when asking the question, “What do I really know to be true?”.

While solipsism shares Descartes’ radical skepticism, it goes beyond it to become irrational. While it’s true that I may be the only being to exist, I cannot live as if that’s true. I must live as if I am surrounded by others who also have minds, and that they are actual beings and not constructs of my mind.

Easter in the KJV

Is the Bible true? Are Bible translations bad? What language is the Bible?

2011 is the 400 year-anniversary of the publication of the King James Bible…so it’s getting a lot of well-deserved attention these days. One kind of attention, however, isn’t so good. The “King James Only” movement exalts the KJV above all other Bibles.

What’s the big deal, you say? You say that it doesn’t seem like preferring one Bible over another is a problem. You’re right. If that’s all it was, nobody would care.

Instead, the KJO movement makes some outlandish statements about God, the Bible, and the King James. It’s not a monolithic movement, so you’ll find that some are more “out there” than others. Here’s a sampling of the kinds of things that KJO folks believe:

  • The King James Version is the only legitimate English Bible.
  • The King James Version was supernaturally translated by God.
  • The King James Version is more accurate than the original Bible manuscripts.
  • The King James Version contains no errors.
  • The King James Version is the only Bible in the world that can be trusted.

Not all KJO advocates believe all of that, of course. Some simpy believe that it’s the most accurate English Bible, and consider it only marginally better than other Bibles. Others believe that to read any other Bible is to take part in a satanic conspiracy to remove the truth from the Gospel story.

Now you can see the problem. It’s a cultic movement.

Any honest and curious student can find that there are errors in the King James Versions of the Bible. That does NOT mean that God’s Word has been compromised, of course…only that the KJO position is based in ignorance. All it takes to show that the KJV is not flawless is a single error. Here’s one of dozens, from Acts 12:4…

And when he had apprehended him, he put him in prison, and delivered him to four quaternions of soldiers to keep him; intending after Easter to bring him forth to the people.

What’s the problem with that? Simple: “Easter” should read “Passover”. That’s the proper translation of PASCHA, which agrees with verses like Matthew 26:2, Matthew 26:17, Matthew 26:18, Matthew 26:19, Mark 14:1, Mark 14:12, Mark 14:14, Mark 14:16, Luke 2:41, Luke 22:1, Luke 22:7, John 6:4, John 11:55, and so on.

I could point to many more examples, but there’s no need. Those who exalt the KJV do so because they don’t know better, or because they refuse to see the truth. Those who don’t know better can look at even a single example and know what’s going on, but those who refuse to see the truth can gloss over 50 such errors without blinking.

I sincerely hope you’re willing to look at the evidence. I’ll post other examples, in case you’re not convinced. KJO folks are notoriously loyal to their point of view, so you should know that I’ve never convinced one of them to drop the nonsensical view that the KJV is flawless. In fact, I lost a Facebook friend just this morning over this very post. He didn’t want “strife” on his page, so he removed me. I would prefer that he do a little homework and see that he’s been leading people astray, but I’m not sure he’s willing.

I’m down a friend. If you’d like to be my friend on Facebook, I promise to continue doing what I’m doing. =)

Should Christians go to Landmark Forum?

Is Intelligent Design true? is evolution wrong? How old is the earth?

A GodWords reader asks:

Going to Landmark Forum if you are a Christian…is this a bad thing?

Marlice

Well, Marlice…thanks for asking!

I’m a Christian, and I went to Landmark Forum. It’s not a bad thing to GO. What IS bad is to listen, and to learn, and to change your life based on their teachings.

Christianity and the teachings of Landmark Forum are not at all compatible! Landmark Forum says that nothing has any value at all, except that which we give it…so there is no right or wrong, no good or bad, no evil, and no sin. A Christian is a follower of Jesus, who taught the opposite. Certain things ARE right and wrong, and we should know the difference. Certain things ARE good and bad, and evil exists. In case you haven’t seen it, I wrote an article on GodWords about a visit to a Landmark meeting, and about my three-hour discussion with the leader afterward. You can read about my Landmark experience.

When someone says that there’s no such thing as sin, they put themselves in God’s place. It’s up to THEM to decide what to do. Christians are not free to do whatever we think is best. Instead, we’re to study Scripture, do what Jesus taught, and listen to the Holy Spirit who lives in us.

I was able to visit Landmark Forum without concern because

  1. I was already aware of much of their teachings,
  2. I’m a mature believer who’s already familiar with what the Bible teaches, and
  3. My goal was to help my friend…she’s been duped by Landmark Forum into believing what can’t possibly be true.

If all three of those are true of you, you can go to Landmark Forum without worry.

If all three are NOT true of you, I’d advise that you not go. Be aware that they are VERY good (as an organization, historically) at manipulation. A quick Google search will show you dozens (if not hundreds) of personal testimonials to the techniques they use. I’m immune to their teachings, but MOST CHRISTIANS ARE NOT. That doesn’t make me special…just more prepared. I’ve spent years studying movements like Landmark Forum, so I’m ready for whatever they might throw my way. If you consider yourself young in the faith at all, I would stay far away from any Landmark meeting.

I’m curious: has someone told you that the teachings of Landmark Forum and Christianity ARE compatible?

Hazardous Holy Water

Is the Eastern Orthodox church the only true church? What do Eastern Orthodox believe?

In Russia, most of the tap water is undrinkable.

In Russia, some folks drank the tap water anyway. Why did they do it? Well, they looked at the calendar and assumed that everything would be different. Yes, I know that sounds odd. It was January 19th, which is when they celebrate Epiphany…when Jesus, who is God become man, was ‘made known’ to the world.

For some reason, these people believe(d) that any water obtained on Epiphany would be “holy” water. For some reason, these people – 117 of them – required medical treatment for acute intestinal pain.

Holy water is traditionally used, by those in the Orthodox tradition, for baptism or for the blessing of people, places, or objects. It may also be used at times in exorcisms. While they claim that the idea of using holy water comes from the Apostle Matthew, there’s no Biblical support for this idea. It can be traced back to around 500 years after Christ, and then only to a story of a man who cast out a demon using water he had blessed. There seem to be many traditions about holy water, but none with strong evidence for how the practice got started.

With all due respect to my Orthodox and Catholic friends, holy water is bunk. The idea is that a holy man can bless the water and give it some kind of spiritual power, which can then be used to make better the lives of those who use it. We see absolutely nothing like that in Scripture, of course…and for good reason: God doesn’t work that way.

Sure, God can and might at any time use water in any way He chooses…but that’s not the same as a priest (or any any regular dude, as the tradition goes) saying a prayer and changing the properties of the water. That’s superstition, pure and simple.

Harold Camping and Jesus’ Second Coming

Don't buy snake oil.

Harold Camping says he knows a thing or two about Jesus’ return.

Born in 1921, Camping claims to have scrutinized the Bible for around 70 years. I suppose it’s his background in engineering that led him to develop a mathematical system to ‘properly interpret’ Biblical prophecy. Camping has crunched the numbers and, according to his latest calculations, was surprised to learn that Jesus will come back on May 21, 2011.

Harold Camping predicts the rapture

Unfortunately for Mr. Camping, this isn’t the first time he’ll be wrong about what’s popularly known as “the Rapture”. On September 6, 1994, dozens of his followers gathered to wait for the big event…only to go home disappointed and disillusioned. Camping suggested that he might have miscalculated when he had written a book about the then-upcoming date titled 1994?.

After running the numbers for another dozen years or so, he’s come to the conclusion that his alternate date from that time was probably correct: May 21, 2011. Want to know how he came up with that date? Camping’s idea is that each word and number in the Bible has a secondary meaning.

The number 5, Camping concluded, equals “atonement.” Ten is “completeness.” Seventeen means “heaven.” Camping patiently explained how he reached his conclusion for May 21, 2011.

“Christ hung on the cross April 1, 33 A.D.,” he began. “Now go to April 1 of 2011 A.D., and that’s 1,978 years.”

Camping then multiplied 1,978 by 365.2422 days – the number of days in each solar year, not to be confused with a calendar year.

Next, Camping noted that April 1 to May 21 encompasses 51 days. Add 51 to the sum of previous multiplication total, and it equals 722,500.

Camping realized that (5 x 10 x 17) x (5 x 10 x 17) = 722,500.

Or put into words: (Atonement x Completeness x Heaven), squared.

“Five times 10 times 17 is telling you a story,” Camping said. “It’s the story from the time Christ made payment for your sins until you’re completely saved.

“I tell ya, I just about fell off my chair when I realized that,” Camping said.

San Francisco Chronicle

Mr. Camping’s calculations have come under fire from Christians, who point to Jesus’ own words in Matthew 24 about His second coming: no one knows the day or the hour of His return, not even He Himself.

I’d like to personally challenge Mr. Camping to act with integrity on May 22, 2011. On that date, it will be refreshing to hear him publicly and undeniably say that he was wrong. I’ve extended the same challenge to other would-be prophets with little success, so I’m not going to hold my breath. I’m just saying that it would be cool to see a retraction.

In case you were wondering, Mr. Camping has not made a retraction.

Pantheism Contradicts Science

Are minds real? Do humans have free will? Is evolution true?

The Greek word PAN means “all”, and THEOS means “god”. Simply put, Pantheism is the view that everything is God. Another way a pantheist might explain it is that nature and God are the same thing. That includes people, planets, and your neighborhood platypus…and everything else.

As I wrote in Materialism Contradicts Science, the universe had a beginning. Something caused it to come into existence. If you’re not up to speed on how the concept of entropy proves that the universe had a beginning, you might want to read that article.

Because the universe had a beginning, Pantheism must be false. Like Materialism, Pantheism presupposes that the universe is all that exists. Because the universe couldn’t create itself, something outside the universe had to do the creating. If the universe is divine, what do we call the being that created the universe? Should we worship the creature, or the creator?

One would think that a Pantheist would welcome the opportunity to readjust their thinking, and to worship the One who created our amazing universe…rather than worshipping the universe itself.

Abortion is a Blessing?

Is abortion wrong? What does the Bible say about abortion?

Reasonable people – on both sides of the abortion issue – believe that the number of abortions needs to be reduced. Whether by adoption, education, or abstinence, almost everyone thinks that abortion is a negative. Unfortunately, there are also a bunch of unreasonable people out there who think otherwise.

katherine_ragsdale

The most radical among us (including those who understand the real reason for the creation of Planned Parenthood) believe that abortion is a good thing. Yes, some of them consider pregnancy a form of male tyranny, and abortion is their cure. Some have much more ‘noble’ reasons for thinking abortion is good. You might be surprised to find that one of these people is an Episcopal minister.

The ability to enjoy God’s good gift of sexuality without compromising one’s education, life’s work, or ability to put to use God’s gifts and call is simply blessing. These are the two things I want you, please, to remember – abortion is a blessing and our work is not done. Let me hear you say it: abortion is a blessing and our work is not done. Abortion is a blessing and our work is not done. Abortion is a blessing and our work is not done.

The Rev. Dr. Katherine Ragsdale

Of course, those of you familiar with the Episcopal church might not be surprised that one of their priests is an openly gay woman who’s served on the board of NARAL Pro-Choice America and the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice. What’s surprising is that she was recently elected as the newest president of Episcopal Divinity School and was the unanimous choice of their Board of Trustees.

Please for pray for those in the Episcopal church, and for those influenced by such godlessness. Please pray for this woman.